Away in a Manger and Susan Boyle

On Monday, I was ready to talk about “Away in a Manger.”  Even though it is still one of my least favorite carols, I have a new-found respect for its origin and the different versions that have been recorded.  According to the origins of Christmas carols, this carol was written around 1883 to celebrate the anniversary of Martin Luther’s 400th birthday.  Historians believe that the song was incorporated into celebratory pageants, perhaps with a figure representing Martin Luther singing this lullaby to his children.   Since Martin Luther’s birthday is November 10, it is not surprising that the tune became associated with Christmas carols.

I  (and Roger because he was sitting next to me) listened to a dozen or so versions of the song. I found that the traditional American tune is much less appealing than the “Sweet Afton” tune written in 1837 by Jonathan Spilman (also called “Cradle Song”).  I loved the Susan Boyle rendition that Jeremy listed in his post.  I thought she was just a television phenom with 15 minutes of fame.  I was surprised to learn that her 2009 album, The Gift,  went platinum in many countries and sold 3,000,000 copies in the United States.  I also liked the version by the Celtic Woman and another by Haley Westerna.

There’s a recording that I haven’t been able to find from 1996 that combines St. Paul’s Anglican Choir singing one version with St. Christopher’s Roman Catholic choir singing the alternate tune.  The idea of the two tunes as a duet sounds lovely.

Roger nominated his favorite version, the King’s College Choir of Cambridge.  I agree that hearing the angelic voices are beautiful.

Lesson learned:  maybe it’s not the song that I dislike after all.  I just needed to find the most appealing version!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s